Evidence for global climate change 1903

Kent Paul Dolan

Ah, rather than trying to defend your irrational arguments, you at least recognize them as fallacies and just "snip them out". I see you wish to try a fresh start. A reformed man, are you?

Oh my stars! You're making it worse, and you don't even understand why!

AT the macroscopic level, we tend to believe that causes have to happen before the effect. (lets leave the tachyon issue out of this for now...) Post Hoc Ergo Propiter Hoc fallacies are a special case of Affirming the consequent.

Causes come before effects. A came before B, Ergo, A is the Cause of B.

This doesn't follow, because just happening before the event doesn't prove causality. It COULD be the cause, but cause is NOT proof of cause .

And as I pointed out, the data from the ice core samples show that the CO2 has risen AFTER the warming in the past. So, CO2 can't be the cause of the past warmings. On the other hand, it remains possible but unproven that warming could be the cause of the CO2!

Now, you're saying that you're not making the fallacy of Post Hoc Ergo Propiter Hoc because you're claimed cause doesn't happen before, but rather at the same time. Same error, but now you are violating the principle of temporal causality. Events separated at any distance at all that happen simultaneously cannot have one the cause, and the other effect. Cause has to happen before the effect (in however small a time period) in all inertial frames, according to Einstein.

You're attempt to prove I misuse them went terribly wrong above, didn't it? Indeed, you've proven you are totally unfamiliar with the concepts of logic and science.

I'm sorry, but you're just too ignorant of logic and science, and too abusive and hateful, for me to bother with discussing this with you.

I don't have to put up with your abuse, and I won't. When mature and can act like a civil, intelligent human being, I shall tutor you further in logic and science. Until then, your anger and hate make you no more suitable for instruction than a rabid dog.