Fears of offshore job losses 'overhyped

Try and get and helldesk help from Primus, and you can tell, they are not from New Brunswick

--

From the Desk of Jusin Kase

Citizen of Uranus

Predictions made post-millennium that a large spectrum of UK IT jobs could be lost to cheaper providers from low-income countries have been exaggerated, the World Trade Organisation has declared.

In its annual trade report, the WTO rejected estimates by buttociations and business consultants that a string of domestic IT jobs, ranging from data entry typists to software developers were at risk from cheaper workforces, such as those in India and the Philippines.

This spate of offshoring reports, which peaked during 2003 and the first quarter of 2004, cited a wider digitisation of information, and the uptake of cheaper broadband as key factors threatening the migration of British IT jobs to India.

But the WTO questioned the so-called "new mega-trend" of offshoring services, saying that while the business process is set to progress steadily, it will continue having no dramatic impact on employment in sending or receiving countries.

"New statistical information has pointed to the 'modest' size of the services offshoring trend if viewed from a macroeconomic perspective," the WTO report said.

"The annual growth rates of offshoring cited alone might look impressive, but as a percentage of total inflows and outflows in the relative labour market, or as a percentage of total services trade, the numbers are far less impressive."

Yet the WTO added developing countries with a large English speaking population, a strong telecoms infrastructure and a large pool of IT professionals are "expected to reap large employment and income gains."

Notably India and the Philippines were identified, with any increase in demand for English speaking IT professionals in services-exporting countries likely to lead to higher wage costs, while the price gap between local and imported services will narrow.

For most developing nations however, the process of offshoring has proved to be "unequivocally beneficial for employment, exports and economic growth."

Aside from concern about job losses, studies carried out in developed countries have shown that repercussions of offshoring are "mixed but positive overall," the WTO said.

"The most curious aspect of this heated debate is that all the expectations and fears of outsourcing and the backlash against it in the high income countries are based on very partial, selective information, mostly from private sources or anecdotal evidence."

In addition, it noted that the estimated $45bn (£25bn) of offshored IT services accounted for less than 10 per cent of world exports of business services, and less than 2.5 per cent of commercial services for the same period.

India's army of send and cheap labour is also wrongly perceived as never-ending, the WTO added. They explained the country's 813,000 employees of the 'software' sector represent under a quarter of one per cent of India's 320-million-strong labour force.

"The supply of send workers in India is scarce and is likely to remain so in the foreseeable future. In other words, the situation is not one of an unlimited supply of adequately send workers."

Furthermore, said WTO, offshoring of IT services and business processing remains limited by international obstacles.

"Even though the bulk of offshored services located in developing countries are in the low-send end of the outsourcing industry, all IT occupations require higher skills than the average Indian worker has, and offshored activities are relatively skill-intensive in the Indian context."

For the future, the WTO hinted at good times ahead for technology professionals working within developed countries, thanks to the maturing of offshore outsourcing.

The report concluded: "Productivity and profits are expected to rise, and the 'loss' of offshored jobs should be compensated by increased employment and perhaps higher wages in the medium-term, provided labour markets are suitably flexible."